100 products

Mjolnir Cookie Cutter
Mjolnir
$20.37
$20.37
Tolting Icelandic Horse cookie cutter
Tolting Icelandic Horse
$17.23
$17.23
Tentacle Cookie Cutter
Tentacle
$17.23
$17.23
SALE
set of alien and ufo cookie cutters
Alien & UFO
$22.47
$22.47
$24.06
Big foot cookie cutter (Large Size)
Big Foot
from $15.69
from $15.69
UFO Cow Abduction Cookie Cutter
UFO Cow Abduction
$17.23
$17.23
anchor cookie cutter
Anchor
$15.13
$15.13
ship wheel cookie cutter
Ship's Wheel
$17.23
$17.23
alien cookie cutter
Alien
$11.99
$11.99
SALE
Set of 3 Cookie Cutters: Pirate Boy, Pirate Flag, Pirate Parrot
Pirate Set (3pcs)
$39.24
$39.24
$44.99
SALE
Anchor, Ship Wheel & Captain Hat Cookie Cutters
Nautical Seamen Set (3pcs)
$39.24
$39.24
$44.99
Viking Ship Cookie Cutter
Viking Ship
$18.28
$18.28
3-Piece Loch Ness Cookie Cutter
3-Piece Loch Ness
$15.13
$15.13
Compass Cookie Cutter
Compass
$17.23
$17.23
valknut cookie cutter
Valknut
$17.23
$17.23
SALE
set of 3 sherlock holmes cookie cutters: Deerstalker hat, magnifying glass, and smoke pipe
Sherlock Holmes Set (3pcs)
$38.19
$38.19
$41.85
SALE
Set of 3 Viking theme Cookie Cutters: Viking Helmet, Viking Shield, and Viking Ship
Viking Set (3pcs)
$41.34
$41.34
$46.04
Money Bag Cookie Cutter
Money Bag
$18.28
$18.28
Kraken Cookie Cutter
Kraken
$24.56
$24.56
SALE
Set of 2 Loch Ness Cookie Cutters
Loch Ness Set (2pcs)
$24.56
$24.56
$29.30
UFO Pizza Abduction
UFO Pizza Abduction
$17.23
$17.23
UFO Man Abduction Cookie Cutter
UFO Man Abduction
$17.23
$17.23
SALE
Set of 3 Cookie Cutters: Treasure Map, Treasure Chest, & Compass
Treasure Hunt Set (3pcs)
$45.53
$45.53
$50.22
Treasure Map Cookie Cutter
Treasure Map
$17.23
$17.23
Gold Coin Cookie Cutter
Gold Coin
$15.13
$15.13
SALE
Set of 3 UFO Abduction Cookie Cutters (Man, Cow, & Pizza)
Classic UFO Abduction Set (3pcs)
$41.34
$41.34
$47.07
Pirate Flag Cookie Cutter
Pirate Flag
$15.13
$15.13
Treasure Chest Cookie Cutter
Treasure Chest
$20.37
$20.37
Captain Hat Cookie Cutter
Captain Hat
$17.23
$17.23
Viking Shield Cookie Cutter.
Viking Shield
$17.23
$17.23
Pirate Parrot cookie cutter
Pirate Parrot
$17.23
$17.23
Pirate Boy Cookie Cutter
Pirate Boy
$17.23
$17.23
SALE
Set of 2 Cookie Cutters: Diving Helmet & Tentacle
Diving Helmet & Tentacle
$28.76
$28.76
$32.43
Diving Helmet Cookie Cutter
Diving Helmet
$18.28
$18.28
ufo cookie cutter
UFO
$15.13
$15.13
Knight Helmet with Plumage
$22.47
$22.47
Cute Knight Face
$18.28
$18.28
SALE
Cowboy Hat & Boot Set
$30.85
$30.85
$31.39
Grey Alien Cookie Cutter
Grey Alien
$18.28
$18.28
SALE
Triskelion and Celtic Triquetra cookie cupcake toppers on green themed cupcakes
Triskelion & Celtic Triquetra Mini Cookie Cutter & Stamp
$26.66
$26.66
$30.25
UFO Abducting Cow Mini Set
$11.99
$11.99
Cowboy Boot Mini Set
$11.99
$11.99
Cowboy Hat Mini Set
$11.99
$11.99
Alien & UFO Mini Set
$22.47
$22.47
Cowboy Ghost
$20.37
$20.37
Cowboy Boot & Hat Mini Set
$20.37
$20.37
Knight on Horse
$24.56
$24.56
Knight Sword
$15.13
$15.13

Enter a world of epic tales and daring feats with our Legends & Adventures Cookie Cutters Collection. Inspired by stories of brave knights, hidden treasure, high-seas pirates, and alien encounters, this collection is made for storytellers, gamers, and bakers with a sense of adventure.

Craft iconic scenes with:

  • Treasure maps, chests, and gold coins for swashbuckling bakes

  • Knight helmets, shields, and swords for fantasy fans and renaissance fairs

  • Vikings, castles, and world maps for history buffs and Norse myth lovers

  • Aliens, UFOs, and abductions for sci-fi geeks and space-themed parties

  • Pirates and diving helmets for seaside adventures

  • Cowboys and adventurers for wild west-inspired cookies

Whether you're baking for a themed birthday, LARP event, or just for fun, these designs spark imagination and serve up a slice of legend with every cookie.